Rubin on 'FDR's Deadly Secret'
The Washington Times
January 11, 2010
FDR'S DEADLY SECRET
By Steven Lomazow, M.D. and Eric Fettman
Public Affairs, $25.95, 259 pages, illus.
Book Review: When the president takes ill
By Martin Rubin
The story of just how ill Franklin Delano Roosevelt was during his presidency---and especially in its final year---is not a new one. Not only was the full extent of his disability from polio not known to most people, but it was revealed two decades after his death in 1945 that he had in fact already been desperately, terminally ill with heart failure when he ran for that unprecedented fourth term in 1944. Now along comes this book claiming that even the story of coronary disease was a cover of sorts: that FDR was actually dying of cancer, specifically a malignant melanoma which had metastasized to his abdomen and brain, in addition to heart disease. . . .
For Martin's full review, click here or visit www.washingtontimes.com.
Friends of Boat Macmurdo Seek Our Help in Honoring Him at LSU
One of Boat Macmurdo's great friends writes to seek our help in a project to name a classroom at LSU Law Center in Boat's honor:
You may remember me from the May, 2007 Memorial Service for Bruce Macmurdo at the Yale Club. It has now been over two years since we lost Bruce Macmurdo. He was my best friend.
As you know, Bruce was a "lawyer's lawyer" who had a great passion for the law - almost as great as his passion for sports. Several of Bruce’s friends, family and close associates have decided to remember and honor him by undertaking to have a classroom at the L.S.U. Law Center permanently named the "R. Bruce Macmurdo Classroom." The cost of this undertaking is $75,000.
We have formed a committee to help raise money for this worthy cause. As committee chairman, I am now reaching out to the Yale community for help in attaining our goal of $75,000. Please help us by your contribution, and by contacting other friends of Bruce in the Yale community.
You can make your contribution by check or by credit card. Checks should be made payable to “LSU Foundation”. The note field should say “Law Center – Macmurdo”. I’ve attached a form for your use [see below].
Thank you for helping to honor a good friend.
With kindest regards, I am
Victor L. Marcello
214 W. Cornerview Street
Gonzales, Louisiana 70707
Office Tele. 225.644.7777 ext. 203
Home Tele. 225.926.5538
Cell 225.907.8783
Home email vmarcello [at] cox [dot] net
..........
Donations Sought for
Bruce Macmurdo Memorial Classroom Project at
Louisiana State University Law Center
Our beloved classmate and former Class Secretary, Bruce Macmurdo, died on January 27, 2007. As many of you may recall, Bruce was a graduate of the Louisiana State University Law Center and a highly accomplished practicing attorney in Louisiana. A committee composed of Bruce’s fellow attorneys, family, and LSU Law Center classmates has decided to honor Bruce by naming an LSU Law Center classroom in his honor.
To make this possible, the committee needs to raise $75,000 and has asked members of the Class of ’71 for help in this effort. The naming gift will require the approval of LSU’s Board of Supervisors and will be designated by permanent signage over the classroom door and a copper plaque in the classroom featuring an etched likeness of Bruce and text commemorating his life and practice.
If you are interested in making a contribution in support of the Bruce Macmurdo Memorial Classroom Project, you can make your contribution by check or by credit card. Checks should be made payable to “LSU Foundation.” The note field should say “Law Center – Macmurdo.” Your check should be mailed to:
Paul M. Hebert Law Center
1 East Campus Drive – Room 400
Louisiana State University
Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70803-1000
ATTN: Karen Soniat
If you wish to pay by credit card, please contact Karen Soniat at the LSU Law Center (telephone: 225/578-8645; email: ksonia2 [at] lsu [dot] edu).
Walt Mintkeski Holiday Letter
Walt Mintkeski writes:
Dear Friends,
This is the latest that I have written my annual holiday letter due to the fact that my 2 day a week contract job with Energy Trust of Oregon (doing energy efficiency for water and wastewater treatment) has turned into a 5 day per week commitment since mid November when our full time engineer left. I hope that my semi-retirement work schedule will return to normal in mid January when the new replacement engineer arrives.
For me, 2009 has been a busy year of transitions. Since turning 60 in April, I have been more mindful that I am a grandfather and the senior member of the Mintkeski Family. I still enjoy commuting by bicycle, racing my Laser sailboat each week, cross country skiing, and backpacking, but I go a little slower. During the year, I completed the process of settling my father’s estate by setting up the Mintkeski Family Fund through the Oregon Community Foundation. Researching and making grant recommendations for our fund to benefit Oregon’s environment is very satisfying and will keep me busy for years to come. An especially meaningful project to me, which my father’s estate made possible, is a 6 kilowatt awning mounted solar system on the south side of The Nature Conservancy building in Portland. It not only generates electricity but also shades the windows from summer sun to keep the building cooler. For the past two years as a volunteer, I coordinated its design and construction. In a ceremony attended by family and friends on July 3, I dedicated the project in his memory, which allowed me to publicly express my tremendous sense of gratitude for all he has given me and taught me as my father.
Vicki and I enjoyed our first full year of grand-parenting and managed to see Toby about every 6 weeks. Watching him grow during his first 18 months has been a real pleasure, experiencing the process of his development which we have forgotten from raising our own two sons at least 28 years ago. We also enjoyed a 10 day winter sunshine vacation in Loreto, Mexico on the Sea of Cortez and a week-long family vacation in NE Washington on the Methow River, with sons Tyler and Charlie, their spouses Maureen and Rachael, and grandson Toby. In August, I went to the Olympic National Park for a 5 day backpack and then to the Siskiyou Wilderness in northern California for a 5 day trail maintenance trip, while Vicki went to Paris and the Dordogne countryside of France with a group of artists. Note: separation really does make the heart grow fonder. Vicki’s trip has inspired her water color painting and teaching. And she continues to enjoy tending our two chickens in the back yard.
Tyler and Maureen (in Seattle) love raising Toby. Tyler has concentrated his work for Smith and Nephew (providing surgeons with metal implants to fix fractures) in the Seattle area so that he has less travel and more time to help with Toby. Charlie and Rachael are enjoying Missoula, Montana so much that they have decided to look for a house to buy. That will probably mean trading some of their backpacking and skiing weekends for house remodeling, but Charlie has the carpentry skills to do it. Rachael has completed her Montessori teaching certification and is enjoying teaching 3 to 6 year olds in a new Montessori school.
So, that is our news. Vicki and I look forward to hearing from you and would love to have you visit us in Portland. Your have my address and phone number below. Keep in touch, and best wishes for the Holidays.
Walt Mintkeski
6815 SE 31st Ave
Portland, OR 97202
503-771-0232
mintkeski [at] juno [dot] com
Elisse Walter Takes Office as an SEC Commissioner, and Faces a Personal Challenge
Congratulations to our classmate Elisse Walter on her appointment as SEC commissioner, and best wishes to Elisse for continued good health in the New Year. In USA TODAY's October 27, 2009 issue, the paper's Washington Bureau chief Susan Page wrote:
"Weeks later, she got a nightmare diagnosis: ovarian cancer.
"What followed was months of juggling the demands of surgery, chemotherapy and a new post that put her at the center of the nation's economic meltdown. Now back at work full time, she talks about the lessons she learned and strategies she employed to handle a high-powered job while dealing with a personal crisis---a situation that others also face in their lives. . . ."
For the full article, click here or visit www.usatoday.com.
Dave Vogel to National Rowing Foundation
Congratulations to Dave Vogel, who's just been named Director of Development for the National Rowing Foundation. The Foundation's announcement reads in part:
A former U.S. national team athlete and coach, Vogel's involvement in rowing at the collegiate and elite level spans four decades.
"I am very excited that we have hired such a high-caliber, experienced development professional for this critical position," said NRF Co-Chairman Anne Martin.
"Dave brings a love of rowing, an understanding of the challenges facing our national teams and a great skill set in fundraising to our organization," said Dick Cashin, a co-chairman and trustee of the NRF. "We are thrilled to have him and I am confident he will be a driving force in taking the NRF to the next level."
A graduate of Yale University, Vogel's rowing career began as a member of the Bulldog lightweight squad in 1967. He went on to serve as men's varsity lightweight coach from 1973-89 and men's varsity heavyweight coach from 1990-2002. At the elite level, Vogel is a three-time national team athlete, competing in the lightweight eight from 1972-74. As a coach, he led the U.S. men's lightweight eight to a silver medal at the 1988 World Rowing Championships and to a fourth-place finish in 1989.
As president of the USRowing Board of Directors from 1995-2000, Vogel led the sport's national governing body during a period of financial and competitive success. A well-known announcer, Vogel has been a key part of the broadcast team for the Olympic Games, World Championships, USRowing National Championships and other major rowing events. Most recently, Vogel worked as a Senior Associate Director of Major Gifts at Yale, a position he held for six years.
"The mission of the NRF has never been more important," said Vogel. "Rowing is expanding on all fronts, and we need to stand ready to meet the increasing financial challenges of the future. The leadership team at the NRF is perfectly suited to this task, and I am eager to join them as their Director of Development." . . .
To read the full announcement, click here or visit www.usrowing.org.
Rubin on Hilary Mantel's 'Wolf Hall'
A Man for All Tasks and Times
Wall Street Journal, October 10, 2009
By Martin Rubin
Although less famous than his great-great-grandnephew Oliver, Thomas Cromwell is well-known, thanks to the enduring fascination of Henry VIII and the Tudor court. Cromwell is of course a memorable villain in the play and movie "A Man for All Seasons"---the royal minister who, cruelly advancing Henry's break with Rome, hounds Thomas More for a loyalty oath that he will not give. Cromwell naturally figured in "King Henry VIII and His Six Wives" (1972), the popular Masterpiece Theater version of these events, and he reappears these days, as dry and determined as ever, in the over-heated HBO series "The Tudors." But for all the portraits of this 16th-century power broker in print and on screen---not to mention in the history books, where he is a central figure in the history of Protestant triumphalism---Cromwell has never before appeared as he does in Hilary Mantel's dense, finely wrought "Wolf Hall," the winner of this year's Man Booker Prize in Britain. . . .
For Martin's full review, click here or visit www.wsj.com.
Two Yale Students Seek Our Reminiscences
By way of the AYA, we've received an invitation from two current Yale students to contribute to a commemorative publication honoring the 40th anniversary of coeducation:
We are Isabel and Emily, two students in Yale College [Emily is Branford '10]. We major in English and Art, and English and Women's, Gender and Sexuality Studies, respectively. As recipients of the legacy of coeducation, we are dedicated to trying to understand what this legacy really means.
To that end, we, with the backing of the Yale College Dean's office, are compiling a commemorative publication in honor of the 40th anniversary of coeducation. Contributions are welcome in the form of personal essays or specific historical examinations, from current students, alums, and faculty.
We are committed to publishing a diverse array of experiences; we believe that every individual voice will benefit Yale, and its current students. If you have any interest in contributing, or any questions, please contact us at yalecoeducationpublication [at] gmail [dot] com.
Coeducation Celebration (Including Link to Photos!)
On Friday, October 9, almost 160 alums and guests met for lunch in the Grand Ballroom at the Yale Club in New York to celebrate the 40th anniversary of coeducation at Yale College. The event was conceived of and organized (beautifully) by Vera Wells and Susan Yecies. Rick Cech and Max Addison took terrific photos, which are posted in the Photo Galleries section of this site---click here to view.
The largest contingent were from '71, though Abby Bloom '72 took the honors for longest distance traveled, having come from Sydney, Australia--joined by, I add, her mother, who came in from Long Island and is 95, and her daughter, who went to Princeton. Many stayed on after the lunch at the Yale Club for afternoon drinks and then dinner.
The speakers---Sam Chauncey, John Wilkinson, Elga Wasserman and Mary Miller, current Dean of Yale College---were for me an unexpected treat. Sam, John and Elga of course were listed as speakers on the invitation, but I hadn't got to know them when we were at Yale, and had imagined them as, well, the Voice of Authority. But they were charming and delightful.
Sam Chauncey spoke on the pre-1968 history of coeducation at Yale, noting among other things that in 1956 Arthur Howe, dean of undergraduate admissions, suggested that women be admitted to Yale, whereupon Whitney Griswold threatened to fire him if he ever mentioned the topic again. Kingman Brewster, who succeeded Griswold, was at the outset opposed to admitting women as undergraduates---as was his wife, Mary Louise---but later became a downright cheerleader for coeducation.
Susan Yecies, introducing John Wilkinson, recalled that as a senior she'd come to babysit for the Wilkinsons and had been confounded by the request to please diaper the baby before he goes to sleep. Susan did not know how to diaper a baby. She called around; none of the other Stiles women knew how either. Calculus, yes; diapers, not so much. Finally, Susan was rescued by Matt Jordan, star of football, track and wrestling.
John Wilkinson began by quoting a line from Scaramouche carved over the entrance to the dining hall in HGS, built in 1932: "He was born with a gift of laughter, and a sense that the world was mad."
"In those would-be revolutionary times of the late sixties, Sabatini's line was apt" despite its overwrought tone (critics derided the novel as a potboiler). "For the world did seem to be more mad than usual, and laughter was becoming an increasingly rare gift" in an era of assassinations, war, and political turmoil.
The events of May Day 1970 were "a tsunami," yet "we do know now, in retrospect, that there was a revolution, a genuine one," John concluded. As Maya Lin's Women's Table depicts, there were some 600 women enrolled at Yale in 1961, when John's wife, Virginia, entered the Graduate School. By the mid-1990s, there were 5,250. "It transformed the entire university."
In 1971 or 1972, Elga Wasserman recounted, she, Georges May and a male undergraduate student came to the Yale Club to explain coeducation to a group of alumni. At the time, as many of us know, the Club had a separate women's entrance. Elga told Georges that if she had to use the women's entrance, she'd refuse to join the panel. She used the main entrance.
Coeducation was approved in November 1968 and implemented in September 1969, and "time pressure was our greatest ally," Elga said. "There was no time for any deliberation." She and Kingman visited Vanderbilt "to decide if it was 'appropriate' for the women---whatever that meant." They knocked on the door of the freshman suite designated for inspection. The door was opened; they peeked in; for some reason there was a box of Tampax on the dresser. "'I think this will do,' said Kingman."
The best thing ever to happen for coeducation, in Elga's view, was May Day 1970. "It unified the student body. Everybody now felt they belonged." Issues of women's varsity athletics were quickly fixed; the female-male ratio was also adjusted, though it was a major issue early on; the scarcity of tenured women faculty remains problematic, though Mary Miller's deanship shows our progress.
Mary grew up in a rural town in New York State and it was only by luck that her father allowed her to apply to one formerly all-male school, which is how she ended up going to Princeton as an undergrad. "I know the resentment that spread among you" when the "1,000 male leaders" line was repeated, she said. She reminded us that when Yale was founded, its mission was to train Congregational ministers. In the 20th century, "it was a fine regional school, with only a few outliers until after World War II." The civil rights movement informed the changes thereafter; "the single most important thing" in the university's becoming a national and an international institution, in her view, was coeducation.
---Katherine Hyde
Bios of our speakers follow:
Henry ("Sam") Chauncey, Jr. '57
I started work at Yale the afternoon of my graduation in 1957 as an Assistant Dean of Yale College. In 1963 I became Kingman Brewster's Assistant. In 1972 I was made Secretary of the University. I pinch hit in admissions, community relations and coordinated administrative matters for coeducation.
In 1982 I left Yale and started Science Park. I went to Gaylord Hospital as President in 1988. In 1995 I returned to Yale to the Public Health School to revitalize the Health Management Program and teach.
I retired in 2000 and live in Vermont where I am on the Boards of Vermont Public Radio, the Vermont Community Foundation, the Vermont Journalism Trust and the State Commission which regulates aspects of hospital expenditures. I am also on the board of a company in NYC and the Board of the Lustman Memorial Foundation in New Haven.
Mary Miller, MA'78, PhD81
Mary Miller, Sterling Professor of History of Art, became dean of Yale College on December 1, 2008. A prominent art historian, Miller has been a member of the Yale faculty since 1981. She was the Vincent J. Scully Professor of History of Art from 1998 until her appointment to the Sterling Professorship ten years later. Prior to assuming the deanship, Miller served as master of Saybrook College for nearly a decade. Her husband, Edward Kamens, is the Sumitomo Professor of Japanese Studies and served as acting master of Saybrook from December 2008 through the end of the 2008-2009 academic year.
Miller has served as chair of the Department of History of Art, chair of the Council on Latin American Studies, director of Graduate Studies in Archeological Studies, and as a member of the Steering Committee of the Women Faculty Forum at Yale.
Specializing in the art of the ancient New World, in 2004 Miller curated The Courtly Art of the Ancient Maya at the National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., and the Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco. For that exhibition, she wrote the catalogue of the same title with Simon Martin, senior epigrapher at the University of Pennsylvania Museum. She is also completing the work of her archaeological project to document and reconstruct the Maya wall paintings at Bonampak, Mexico.
For her work on the Maya, Miller has won national recognition including a Guggenheim Fellowship. She was elected to the American Academy of Arts and Sciences in 1994. She has been chosen to deliver the two most prestigious lecture series in her discipline: she will give the Mellon Lectures at the National Gallery of Art in spring 2010 and the Slade Lectures at Cambridge University in 2014-2015.
Elga Wasserman, JD'76
After graduating from Smith College and earning a PhD in chemistry at Radcliffe/Harvard, I worked in various capacities as a chemist in industry and academia while raising three young children. I began working at Yale as assistant dean of the Graduate School in 1962 and remained there until November 1968, when President Brewster asked me to oversee the admission of women undergraduates to Yale College in the fall of 1969, together with Sam Chauncey. I worked as Brewster's Special Assistant and as Chair of the Coeducation Committee until 1973, when I entered Yale Law School as a member of the class of 1976.
After graduation from law school, I spent one year clerking on the Second Circuit Court of Appeals. From 1977 until 1994 I practiced law in New Haven. I spent the next five years writing a book based on interviews with the relatively small number of women who had been elected to the National Academy of Sciences, "The Door in the Dream: Conversations with Eminent Women in Science", published in 2000 by the Joseph Henry Press, a division of the National Academy Press. Since that time I have lectured widely on women, science, equal opportunity and the lack thereof and gradually retired. My husband and I moved to Lexington, Massachusetts in 2006 and are now enjoying spending more time with our family, trying to stay fit, and forming many stimulating new friendships.
John A. Wilkinson '60, MAT'63, MAH'79
I arrived in New Haven in September, 1956, as a freshman in an all male, mostly homogeneous Yale College and left in 1974 as Associate Dean of Yale College and Dean of Undergraduate Affairs to complete the coeducation of a secondary school, which had been resolutely all male for over 300 years. In those eighteen years at Yale as student in three schools and in several roles as a dean, I participated in a magnificent transformation of the University, one which was always exciting, sometimes even frightening, but with a stunningly positive effect.
My second act at Yale was with my classmate Bart Giamatti, who brought me back as VP for Development and then Secretary of the University. Those nine years were no less exciting, though the challenges often differed, but again Yale became a better and stronger institution, a truly great international university. All this prepared me for two more stints as a head of school, one Quaker and the other Benedictine, again leading one to coeducation, and ultimately back home to New Haven to an active, though less stressful, retirement.
Rubin on 'Harvard Beats Yale 29-29'
HARVARD BEATS YALE 29-29
By Kevin Rafferty
Overlook Press, $35, 175 pages, illus.
REVIEWED BY MARTIN RUBIN, The Washington Times, October 18, 2009
This book not only tells the story of one of the most historic and exciting college football games in the Ivy League, but also provides a marvelous snapshot of a particular time. The game took place on a cold Saturday (I can attest to that as I was one of the many thousands of spectators freezing in the stands as the wind blew in off the River Charles), Nov. 23, 1968. Not everything that happened in the Sixties was about drugs or protesting the Vietnam War, although that comes into it, and some of the peripheral figures would loom large in other spheres decades later. . . .
For Martin's full review, click here or visit www.washingtontimes.com.
Rubin on 'Yale Biographical Dictionary of American Law'
Giving all the lawyers their due
The Washington Times, Thursday, July 23 2009
The Yale Biographical Dictionary of American Law
Edited by Roger K. Newman
Yale University Press, $65, 622 pages, illus.
Reviewed by Martin Rubin
Many readers are quick to dismiss reference books as dry, dull stuff---and all too often, unfortunately, they are right. But certainly not in the case of this marvelous, multifaceted pointilliste portrait of the good, the bad and the ugly faces of American jurisprudence through the centuries. . . .
Sometimes this book even answers questions that many might have had. How many of those who visit or even pass by the Criminal Court Building in downtown Los Angeles know anything about the woman for whom it is named, Clara Shortridge Foltz?
One of the volume's characteristically brief but nonetheless admirably succinct and fact-filled entries informs us that she was not only the first woman admitted to the California bar after a fierce struggle in 1878, but that she conceived the notion of a public defender for those accused who could not afford one. She lived to see California enact the Foltz Defender Bill in 1921. Since most of the accused in the courthouse named for her are, for good or ill, represented by public defenders, clearly this was a particularly apt choice. . . .
For Martin's full review, click here or visit www.washingtontimes.com.